The Complexities of Club vs. Country
Why the US won't field its strongest team at the 2023 U20 World Cup
As the U.S. men's U-20 team prepares for their opening match against Ecuador at the 2023 U-20 World Cup, the squad won't be at its full potential. The tournament doesn't fall in a FIFA-mandated international window, which means clubs aren't required to release their players. This leads to a complex web of decisions for clubs, players, and federations, all of whom must weigh the pros and cons of participation.
What does it mean for clubs?
Clubs like Chicago Fire must face the harsh reality of balancing their own interests with the players' desires. The Fire declined to release midfielder Brian Gutierrez and goalkeeper Chris Brady, as they are key members of the team during a packed schedule. Meanwhile, Croatian side Hajduk Split also decided not to release American midfielder Rokas Pukstas.
The case of LA Galaxy's center back Jalen Neal further exemplifies the delicate decision-making process. Neal has played a crucial role for the Galaxy and with the recent injury of another center back, his absence would be felt. LA Galaxy head coach and sporting director Greg Vanney must carefully weigh the pros and cons of letting Neal participate in the U-20 World Cup.
The timing of the tournament puts MLS clubs in a particularly precarious situation. The early part of the MLS season clashes with the U-20 World Cup, forcing clubs to make difficult choices between developing players and securing points. San Jose Earthquakes sporting director Chris Leitch acknowledges this challenge, emphasizing the need for collaboration with players and the importance of considering the long-term benefits of international experience.
Aside from the emotional and developmental aspects, there's also a financial element to consider. Participation in the U-20 World Cup can increase a player's market value, as clubs worldwide closely watch the performances of young talent. However, scouting has become increasingly sophisticated, and players like Jalen Neal are already on the radar of European clubs.
Keep reading with a 7-day free trial
Subscribe to It's Called Soccer to keep reading this post and get 7 days of free access to the full post archives.